Rubric

Find Rubric
Keep in mind that 20 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
Writing Assignment Rubric (1)
Writing Assignment Rubric (1)
Criteria Ratings Pts
Thesis
threshold: pts
5 pts
Exemplary thesis statement, thesis addresses the assigned topic and adds original understanding of key questions, clear, effective transitions between ideas (topic sentences maintain focus)
4 pts
Clear theses statement, thesis addresses the assigned topic
3 pts
Thesis statement does not clarify a particular standpoint or simply repeats the assignment. Paper proceeds without clear transitions between paragraphs.
2 pts
Ideas confusing, disconnected, purpose is unclear, thesis posed as announcing, (“In my paper I will discuss. . .”), topic sentences nonexistent or random
1 pts
No clear thesis statement, fails to address assignment, lacks focus and organization
pts
5 pts
--
Argument
threshold: pts
5 pts
Argument is presented clearly, logically, and proceeds smoothly to writer's conclusion. Logical points build directly upon the thesis and prior points. Key texts are summarized with focus on the important points and conter-arguements or a clear point of view is expressed in regard to the author's argument.
4 pts
Argument is presented clearly and logically, but points do not necessarily build on each other. The author's main argument is addressed but key points are left hanging or are dealt with inadequately. Conclusion does not relate back to thesis.
3 pts
Argument is unfocused. It does not logically precede or build upon itself. Lacks evidence from texts and class discussions. Does not express a standpoint or clear view on the author's argument.
2 pts
Argument is rambling, and there are contradictions left unaddressed. Counter arguments may be presented, but are left unaddressed.
1 pts
There is no discernable argument, or no alternative interpretation is presented.
pts
5 pts
--
Application of reading/ concepts
threshold: pts
5 pts
Demonstrates insight into major themes of the reading, using lectures and discussions to define concepts. Argument is placed within the broad discussions outlined in the course. Thus, demonstrates critical thinking.
4 pts
Concepts are defined and discussed, but the author does not demonstrate insight into the major themes of the course relevant to the argument.
3 pts
Little broader framework is used to present and analyze key concepts. Course readings are used. Concepts are left undefined, or poorly defined.
2 pts
Several points of the argument are left without evidence. Evidence is insufficient.
1 pts
Paper mentions course readings, but there is little demonstration of how the paper relates to the course.
pts
5 pts
--
Writing, Organization, and Clarity
threshold: pts
5 pts
Clear organization with a natural flow. Includes an introduction, transition sentences to connect major ideas, and conclusion. There are are no grammar or spelling errors. Minimal passive voice. Ideas and evidence are correctly cited. Uses one of each of the following citation forms: 1 free paraphrase, 1 shorter citation, 1 block quote, as stated in the assignment.
4 pts
Clear organization, with introduction, transitions and conclusion, but writing is not always fluid. There are several grammar or spelling errors. Ideas and evidence are correctly cited. Uses some of the following citation forms: 1 free paraphrase, 1 shorter citation, 1 block quote.
3 pts
Student presents a thesis but the organization of the argument is then unclear and lacks focus. There are several grammar and spelling errors. Uses some of the following citation forms: 1 free paraphrase, 1 shorter citation, 1 block quote.
2 pts
Organization is unclear or without necessary component parts. Significant grammar or spelling errors (but not both). Ideas and evidence are correctly cited. Uses only one of the following citation forms: 1 free paraphrase, 1 shorter citation, 1 block quote.
1 pts
Little discernable organization. Significant grammar and spelling errors. Ideas and evidence are not correctly cited, or not cited at all. Uses none of the following citation forms: 1 free paraphrase, 1 shorter citation, 1 block quote.
pts
5 pts
--
Total Points: 20 out of 20